I replaced joystick in hori RAP v5 xbox/pc version. It is 20 min max job and it works out of box. I personally prefer this joystick to hori original one. I also added 30MM FOAM WASHER SILENCER FOR SANWA/SEIMITSU BUTTONS to 8 main buttons (available from arcadeworld). Noise level now it equivalent to drumming fingers on desktop.
I play Tekken on both PC/XBOX. I could not play in same room when somebody else watch TV etc. Now it is not issue. Really like new setup. I like arcadeworld services.